Thursday, March 21, 2013

Before Sunset Reflections



I suppose in retrospective that saying that Celine and Jesse would meet again but not under the promised pretenses would have been a safe bet to make in my reflection for Before Sunrise but I guess we can all be half right in our respective assumptions on whether or not we thought they would meet in the promised 6 month time span. I have to say off the cuff that I did rather enjoy the film, and while the ending was not what I would consider ideal or realistic in any stretch of the imagination we have to carefully remember that the story between the two lovers in nowhere near ideal or realistic, nor are the lovers themselves. If Jesse and Celine had to be grouped into a particular relationship archetype I would see them as the ones that almost got away, not quite the fated couple or the star crossed lovers but rather old flames that never died out fully.  While in Before Sunrise Jesse was seen as the bright eyed young adventurer and Celine the beautiful yet bored damsel in distress of her own making, the characters didn’t progress much in terms of moving beyond those roles in the sequel. Instead they are both seen as slightly older versions of themselves yet Jesse is still gallivanting across the globe, only this time as a successful writer, and Celine is still making her normal life miserable for herself despite her apparent success.  Celine is seen as having fallen into a sort of dormant romantic state, a strange mid ground between being in love and wanting to be loved; instead she wants to feel love on her end. To me Celine is facing the rare predicament of being the beloved, placed so high on the pedestal that she is isolated from experiencing the feelings that other have for her. She experiences an absence of feeling because being with Jesse for that short albeit intense 24 hour time span has effectively raised her threshold for what she sees as the ultimate high of love to the point where no one else can stimulate her feelings. However can the feelings that exist between the two really be referred to as love, perhaps it drifts dangerously close to the desire side of the boarder. In the cafĂ© scene of the film where the two discuss desire I found it oddly reminiscent of the famous telephone scene at the restaurant in the first film, Jesse openly address what it’s like to be freed from your desires but Celine steadfastly counters that desire is a necessity for life most likely due to their predicament where Jesse has spent the last 9 years trying to let this girl go and she has spent the past 9 years being resentful about letting him slip through her fingers.

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Steve Almond

On the 12th of March in the year 2013 an amazing writer named Steve Almond came to give a lecture about his writing on the themes of love and desire, and a certain prosthetics and orthotics major who attended his lecture would never be the same again. In all seriousness Mr. Almond was a fantastic lecturer and if given the chance I would most definitely attend another lecture given by him, he had an amazing presence and charismatic control of the audience which let it be known that this was an open forum for any kind of question. However keep in mind that it was no holds barred on his end and that if you asked a question you were going to get your answer regardless of whether or not you were really ready for the answer. Mr. Almond had the amazing ability to take 2 of the things in this world that make me the most uncomfortable, put them together, and make a rather nice story about called Skull. Based on my chosen field of studies you can assume one of two things about me, either A. that I am an amputee fetishist, or B. that I am terrified of amputee fetishists. I hate to spoil it for you but I fall in the latter category, anything involving that subject is incredibly uncomfortable for me, after all I'm trying to put them back together once they've been stripped down not strip them down and then put them back together. Therefore addressing that this is a unique career issue that people come across from time to time is something that I have wholly avoided thus far no thanks to Mr. Almond! The other factor to my discomfort was the graphicness of his sex scenes, graphic literary sex scenes are something that I have never been too keen on, after all when you follow a character you watch them grow and surmount obstacles, its like watching a dear friend progress through a period in their life, and do you really want to watch your dear friends describe sex on a brutally honest level? I certainly hope not. All of this being said I am glad that this happened because while he took me to a peak of some very extreme discomfort he didn't leave me there, just like the main narrator of his story, he took us there and back to the safe place of understanding without abandoning the reader or the character.  The way Mr. Almond treats his characters is the way a lot of people wish they could confront life, a gentle hand pushing them towards both good and bad but never ever abandoning them along the way. When he read Skull aloud I was shocked, but by the end of it once I had taken a moment to process everything I appreciated that Mr. Almond was such a fantastic writer, I wasn't alone in my experience, I was right there with the narrator sitting on his couch internally begging his buddy to not continue down the path of over sharing, and while we were both powerless to stop the experience (a feeling akin to watching a train wreck: frozen by the horror but its too good to look away) we are wiser people for it. The way that Mr. Almond applies the themes of love and desire to his work is amazing to put it simply,  He treats it as a challenge to himself as a writer to be able to successfully portray this complex set of human feelings. Sure he could have chosen a different set of equally complex feelings like grief and misery, but by portraying love and desire he challenges himself to work past the cliche fantasy of love that most art forms abuse. Just like he noted in his lecture that pornography is the fantasy of sex, I saw a parallel that most mediums in the art world are a fantasy of love but that desire has the unique ability to persist as something not quite artificial in either portrayal.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Sexuality and The Police State (Halfaouine)

Like  most films for this class I like to go in with a blank palate and an open mind so I try my hardest to resist the ever nagging temptation to just go ahead and look up all of the spoilers a girl would ever need, and in this case I am especially glad that I was able to resist that temptation because I feel like going into this film blindly really opened me up to not passing an early judgement on it. Halfaouine is an onion of a film if there ever was one, layers upon layers of different meanings, the film is still quite enjoyable on the superficial end of things, more risque on the innuendo level, and a serious allegory in the subtext, but overall I think that any open minded audience (generally the same population of viewers that don't mind subtitles) could find a good lens to see things through that helps relate the movie to their own life. Now granted without Dr. Lang's lecture I will be the first to admit that I would have missed out on the entire allegorical subtext that alludes to the change of power in contemporary Tunisia which was an incredibly powerful realization for me and it gave the film so much more of an impact. At first it came off as a slightly risque and goofy coming of age film with undertones of civil unrest. The undertones of civil unrest I felt were mirroring the unrest that adolescent Noura was feeling with his place in society, being too old to be privy to the secret lives of women yet too young to be able to run with the bulls so to speak. At that point in life Noura faces the challenges of gaining recognition in the eyes of male society while at the same time having to betray the trust that the female society puts in him as an innocent young boy, we see this when he steals his aunts bras and trades them to a local teenager, when he infiltrates the bath house to spy on the local girls, and when he tricks the young beautiful housemaid into some suggestive situations. Noura feels uncomfortable being in between these two worlds as we can see when he seeks maternal comfort after getting in trouble, yet I cant help but wonder is the maternal world being too coddling for Noura? Being the first born son in any culture sort of puts you at an automatic predisposition to be spoiled beyond all belief and from my view point his mother was too protective and too babying, while on the other hand his father was nowhere near the father figure that he needed. In a society where a young man can only prove himself as a man by being defiant and acting out sexually there is no real place for a 12 year old and Noura was forced to grow up too early in my eyes, however when portrayed by the film its clear that he didn't mind at all. To bring it all together Nouras coming of age reminded me oddly enough of the story of creation and the banishment of Adam and Eve. Where we can see God and the garden of Eden as the fruitful maternal nurturing private sphere of women where young Noura was safe, and then once tempted by thought of growing up and knowing the world of men Noura subsequently banishes himself from the women's world by gaining knowledge he was not yet meant to have and is therefore doomed to spend the rest of his young life toiling for the things he once had such free access too.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Love and desire in the Penny Press

As corny as it sounds I thoroughly enjoyed Dr. Burt's style of correlational research because this was the first time I had really seen it done in a proper and approachable way. In her presentation she outlined the exact way she went about doing the research in a manner that practically help our hand and guided us through the process. In most fields we are cautioned about correlational research because "correlation is not causation" said about 80 past and present professors of mine, however Dr. Burt used this style of research to its strongest advantage: the researcher cannot affect the trends of the data. Now while anybody can skew their data, historical research has the benefit of not creating an environment where the data will be altered due to the presence of an on going study. However that being said on to more important things like her presentation itself. Dr. Burt's presentation was very enjoyable, from my perspective it was like being taught the proliferation of "the rag", you know those of sub-par newspapers whose contents you might need a 3rd grade education at best to decipher its more complex stories. The wood block cuts and scans of old New York Times issues were like seeing early cave paintings that would evolve into US weekly, but I suppose the most interesting thing about her lecture was the view of a woman's place in the that day and time and thinking about it in retrospective I wouldn't have lasted a day. I guess its kind of taken for granted that nowadays we have the freedom to pursue higher education (or education of any kind for that matter). I cant help but to speculate if shortly after the time period covered by Dr. Burt did the readership of the penny press turn more sharply towards the female audience? and if so is this where the stereotype of the female gossip obsession stems from for America? Thinking about it now, if the only female oriented writing was about gossip then there wouldn't be much else out there for young women growing up, especially in the boring domestic sphere, in fact that kind of seclusion could have easily tailored the popular taste of women towards that kind of stimulation. While the sentimental writing was described by Dr. Burt as prescriptive literature used to teach moral values and act as examples and cautionary tales to vulnerable young ladies I can also see this kind of scintillating gossip rag being used as a different kind of prescriptive literature, the kind that cures boredom. As low brow as it may come across I believe that the popular literature among the working class american citizens in the industrial revolution offered a kind of romantic escapism for the women of the day, it was an accessible way to breath new life into old surroundings for those trapped housewives similar to the way Emma Bovary found her escapism in different affairs.

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Ancient Love and Desire

I really fell in love with Dr. Freunds lecture, which was the whole point of this class right? all kidding aside I do have an openly known soft spot for Greek art so when he started linking the usage of some of the Greek artistic staples in the Jewish culture I was floored, to me the two worlds were never meant to meet and yet they did and it went quite swimmingly. The use of symbols and religious iconography is something that's been present for almost as long as religion has been around whether it was a physical artistic interpretation or a literary interpretation so touching on the roots and the taboo nature of such a thing is huge. The key points that really struck me in this lecture were closely related in my eyes, Dr. Freund left us with the open ended questions of why was Leda and the swan depicted on a Jewish tomb, and why was Zeus abducting ganymedes found on the frieze of a synagogue? My only speculative answers for Dr. Freund stem from my very light background in Greek art and architecture: They were warning signs. Yes, a popular theory I'm sure but it holds some merit. If the Jews believed that idols of Astarte could help with fertility and were allowable by their religion because they weren't really worshiping it and just using to as a good luck charm then they could have just as easily followed the same pattern with the horrific themes of Greek art. It was a very common practice for the ornate temples of ancient Greece to feature horrible creatures and monsters of folk lore such as the Medusa that was pictured directly next to Zeus and Ganymedes on the synagogue frieze. These images were intended to bar evil from entering the house of worship, sort of like an ancient form of a home security system, so instead of ADT protecting a suburban cookie cutter house you would have the gaping maw of Medusa protecting a sacred temple. I think the theme of the frieze was designed to stay within the themes of Greek culture because they were popular images, and perhaps did not violate the commandment that banned the creation of religious iconography after all according to the Jewish religion Zeus, Ganymedes, and Leda never existed. While Zeus and Ganymedes are not as horrible at face value I think the story could have easily been used a cautionary tale following along the lines of "That's something the Greeks would do, however we would never do something like that and here is a reminder to keep you on the straight and narrow!". I feel like the depiction of Leda and the swan on the tomb could be explained along the same lines, the image beautifully condemns 2 horrific acts at once: bestiality and rape. The image of the vulnerable woman and the attacking swan is both beautiful and terrifying, something that could be used as both protection for the dead and ornamentation for the living. In the back of my mind there is another simple explanation for the occurrence of the images: were the stories ever censored? while it may sound ridiculous it wouldnt be the first time censorship has occluded historys view of the world. Imagine if the graphic nature of these myths had been lost in translation? and that the stories were "simplified" to preserve the popularity of the art across cultures, if someone did come across the true story they might have been so shocked that they would have spread the word around and eventually Ganymedes and Zeus become a boy being protected by one of gods fiercely loving creatures, and Leda and the swan could have become simply the beautiful Leda having her purity artfully protected by one of gods most loving creatures. Now image if you you reviewed the images with that being your only background information, desire and lust are transformed into love and protection so easily it could fool you.

Thursday, February 14, 2013

Lecture 2: Seeking love after divorce

I found Dr. Miller-Otts lecture this week very interesting because for once I could relate from a more personal level as many of my classmates could as well. After hearing the title of the lecture I was honestly expecting a very dry technical presentation of numbers and rough correlations, but instead I was treated to the most enthusiastic of lecturers and a relateable presentation where her research was very well thought out and presented from the human aspect. Several things from this presentation interested me to a fairly good degree, granted I have little to no experience with "social" research but the view points that she presented on her topic were very well put and opened up her ideas to further consideration. The key point that stuck out to me the most was the concept of selective disclosure between former spouses, here you have two people who have spent a considerable amount of time working up the courage to feel comfortable enough to tell one another everything and then that all is cut off very abruptly. The expected issues that would result from this are perhaps feelings of abandonment coupled with vulnerability due to information that you can't take back and followed up with little to no further disclosure. For example during my own parents divorce watching one try to communicate with other was literally like watching a dentist trying to pull teeth  from a patient with lockjaw, and even after it was finalized the amount of information that they were willing to disclose to each other bordered on what you would feel open enough telling the barista at your local Starbucks and what you might chat about with your gas station attendant. Now all of this being said I am not trying to generalize that all former spouses display this level of control over their right to disclose information but I did find that part of her research quite true to life. Social disclosure is something we all deal with regardless of being married at one point in your life, after all this is how we bond with people on a basic level and form meaningful relationships and we have all felt the consequences of learning the levels of appropriate versus inappropriate disclosure the hard way. Putting this all into perspective in terms of my own life makes me wonder how the different forms of love relate to the level of disclosure, considering that the amount of love could hypothetically relate to a "number" level of disclosure and the same could be said for a negative number, or the backlash of what occurs when the love is replaced by hate. On a conceptual level the amount of disclosure the average person is willing to commit to in any given relationship could be associated with a certain magnitude of love where the amount of actual affectionate love would be indicated on the positive side of the scale and the amount of disdain and hate would be on the negative side of the scale with complete indifference falling in the middle at a zero. While there is no true way to measure this kind of thing due to the subjectivity of its nature Dr.Miller-Ott went about her research in a similar fashion; doing the best to narrow down the core feelings of the participants to single out common occurrences in all of them. I guess it would be safe to say that I thoroughly enjoyed her lecture because we had not really had the chance to touch on what happens after love that doesn't end in some tragic suicide.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Dr. Borcks lecture on love and friendship in relation to postmodern politics was a very refreshing perspective that we have yet to see in this class.  When we discuss love and desire in this course and the coupled one that took place last semester we normally discussed these "issues" in the context of art, literature, and personal relations. When discussing love and desire we have put a strong emphasis on the image of the other created to ultimately fill a void in the self, however Dr. Borcks research brings to light the different kinds of love and pondered by Plato and it put a stronger emphasis on our concept of the other and where it comes from and why we can either love it or be threatened by it. While I'm sure most people, much like myself found the work of Carl Schmidt hard to stomach his principle piece, the concept of the political, brought to light that the other can fall into two categories: The friend and the enemy. While Schmidts points on this dichotomous relationship were valid I felt he put far too much of an emphasis on the enemy and the meaning of it, without developing the idea of the friend much at all. From one view point I can understand that defining one through knowing the other is a perfectly acceptable way of understanding a concept however in this case he fell very short only because the issue is so complex. When Dr. Borck discussed the view point of naming the enemy says something about ones self and that by doing so a fraternal kinship is created with the enemy due to a certain kind of common ground likeness it really struck a cord with me. This begins to enter the area of questioning that revolves around what is the opposite of love, the first answer is always hate, however from my experiences when asked to define hate we say that it is the opposite of what we love. Therefore the two halves share a strong connection, somewhat like a mirrored image, essentially the same yet the complete opposite and this is where our hate of the enemy is born. That fact that we see all of the faults we wish to see fulfilled within the beloved exaggerated and exposed in the "hated" only makes us resent them more, its like a magnifying glass for imperfections. To bring it back to more of "Schmidt" styled answer think about the world political situation, as a world super power the US has a habit of wanting to correct and develop other nations, mostly ones with poor infrastructure and a unfairly governing body, but why is this? according to this theory we wish to do that because we can identify with the nation, we were there once and we refuse to be there again. By fearing a return to some sort of totalitarian regime and the decay of all we have worked for we try and fix these problems when we see them in other nations, out of some sort of disdain and hatred for the ruling body because it reflects what we never wish to be. On the other hand we have our allies, the other world powers with stable economies and fair ruling systems that we wish to best be and by being among their ranks we feel better about ourselves. The fraternal kinship that is commonly associated with the allies also works strongly for our relationships with our enemies because when taken out of our everyday concept of brotherly love it also encompasses brotherly resentment and brotherly competition.